FAQ  •  Login

Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 8:10 am

Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

(This is going to be extremely long. Anyone who reads the whole thing: thank you for your patience and interest!)

I did the Hoon Competition with the idea of (a) testing the simple sliding-scale desirability system my economist friend and I came up with and (b) getting my feet wet on the running-a-forum-competition side of things. What with the new update adding engineering times, engineering costs, and tooling costs, it's looking like a good time to start planning the competition that I really wanted to do: a full Car Tycoon Challenge, in the spirit of yore, with multiple market demographics, limited production runs, and everything.

(The scary thing is, the following isn't even the full complexity of what I want to do - this is all based on the principle that every customer will buy the best car for them, but starry-eyed as I am about what I hope to eventually do, I'm still trying to climb the stairs only three or four steps at a time.)

Here's my thinking so far.

Build Rules

  • Each player/team entering is allowed to submit one or two cars. If they submit two cars, they can be different models or different trims of a single model, and they can be powered by different engine families or different variants of one engine family [edit 2015-12-05: or the same variant, even].
  • Each model and each engine family will have an Engineering Time limit. If you have one trim/variant on a model/family, that trim/variant can use up to the entire limit. If you have two trims/variants, then (pending the eventual in-game calculations of shared costs) total Engineering Time, Engineering Costs, and (at least for engines) Tooling Costs will each be taken as the larger value among the two trims/variants plus half the smaller.
  • As in the Hoon Competition, I will have fuel type and Safety requirements based on the in-game markets. (This time it will probably be Gasmea, the default.)
  • I'll probably drop the restrictions on intake, headers, catalytic converter, and mufflers - at most, I'll have a noise-limit restriction. Naturally, reliability > 0 will still be a requirement.
  • Players will choose factory size and % cost markup in-game for each trim. (Is factory size by trim or by model? I'll need to figure that out before I start the competition.) Factory size will determine maximum number of cars built. (For this competition, I'm assuming cars built = cars sold, but like I said above, I Have Plans.)

Desirability Calculations

  • The basic formula for desirability within each demographic will follow the same structure as desirability the Hoon Competition - positive dollars for each of the available categories, negative dollars for running costs and some fraction of sticker price. (It might be 15%, same as the Hoon Competition, or it might vary by market demo - haven't decided.)
  • ...with one change: the fuel costs will have a multiplier based on demographic. (Commuter cars are probably driven a lot more miles than Track cars.)
  • The positively-scored statistics will be the five basic stats plus four others:
    • Drivability
    • Sportiness
    • Comfort
    • Prestige
    • Safety
    • Practicality
    • Utility
    • Offroad
    • Reliability
    ...and the weights on these categories for each demographic will probably be shown in spider/radar charts like this (numbers in thousands of $):
    sample demo radar chart.png
    sample demo radar chart.png (12.73 KiB) Viewed 7921 times

    (colors will change to match the default forum style and visual design will be generally improved before the competition.)
  • Each demo will also have a definited statistical budget distribution. (Probably lognormal.) Customers will only buy cars within their budgets, as you'll see later.
  • Number of market demographics is going to be kept low, and each demo is going to be clearly distinct from each other. (This is part of my long-term plan.) I'll probably talk about the seven demos I've come up with so far in a later post. (I may also provide a spreadsheet with all these numbers and spaces for minimum-maximum scores in each category - set to default values based on my predicted ranges - for players to use for planning purposes.)

Sales Calculations

The size of the market will scale with the number of entries. Probably something along the lines of x million + y million per entrant, with an appropriate cap on the number of entrants. (As you can see, calculations get very cumbersome the more cars there are.)

(The following is the really complicated part.)

The calculation of sales is based on repeated application of a basic formula for distributing sales between various available cars (and the $0-cost, $0-desirability "I'm not buying a car" option), based on the idea of a normally-distributed variation in desire that I'm calling Idiosyncrasy.
  • The highest desirability car available gets a sales score of 1.
  • Each other car will get a sales score based on phi, the normal-distribution CDF, equal to
      Code:
            / this - best  \
    2 * phi( -------------- )
            \ idiosyncrasy /


    This is proportional the probability that a customer's random preferences over things like styling, brand, nation of origin, and the like will lead them to value this specific car over the stats-based favorite. (Note that this formula gives 1 for the highest desirability car.)

    For example: if idiosyncrasy = $1000 in a demo, there are three cars in the demo, and they have values $5000, $4000, and $3000, then the sales scores work out to 1, 2 * 0.1587 = 0.3174, and 2 * 0.0228 = 0.0456, respectively.
  • When sales are distributed, they are distributed proportionally to sales scores. (In the above example: 73.4%, 23.3%, and 3.3%, respectively.) (Note that if two cars were tied, they would split sales exactly evenly.)

After entries to the competition are closed, the cars will be sorted by price, from most to least expensive. This done, a table will created for each demographic, with rows for each car containing:
  1. Car ID
  2. Price
  3. Fraction of customers in demographic who can afford this car, but not the next most expensive
  4. Desirability for this car
  5. Sales scores as above for this car and every car below it on the list
  6. Sales scores, renormalized to sum to the fraction in (c).
The renormalized sales scores can then be summed in columns to calculate what fraction of the market demographic was sold to each car.

Example (somewhat truncated):

  Code:
idiosyncrasy = $1000

ID || Frac Desirab |    A       B       C      0   |    A       B       C       0
---||--------------|-------------------------------|--------------------------------
A  || 0.5   $5000  | 1.0000  0.0456  0.3174 0.0000 | 0.3668  0.0167  0.1164  0.0000
B  || 0.2   $3000  | 0.0000  0.3174  1.0000 0.0004 | 0.0000  0.0482  0.1518  0.0000
C  || 0.2   $4000  | 0.0000  0.0000  1.0000 0.0004 | 0.0000  0.0000  0.1999  0.0001
0  || 0.1   $0     | 0.0000  0.0000  0.0000 1.0000 | 0.0000  0.0000  0.0000  0.1000
---||--------------|-------------------------------|--------------------------------
                                                     0.3668  0.0649  0.4681  0.1001

(As you can see, being affordable to 90% of customers nets C more sales than A, even though A is the better car, and being inferior to a cheaper car costs B dearly.)

These fractions are calculated for every demographic and, when multiplied by the total number of customers in each demographic, give the number of cars of each model sold.

Unless, of course, one or more cars sell out their entire production run. If this happens...

*sighs*

...when this happens, I will find what fraction of the total number of customers were served before that car ran out, record sales for that number of customers, and start a new sheet on the spreadsheet without the sold-out car and with all remaining customers.

If, in the example above, C above sold out, the new spreadsheet would look like:
  Code:
idiosyncrasy = $1000

ID || Frac Desirab |    A       B      0   |    A       B       0
---||--------------|-----------------------|------------------------
A  || 0.5   $5000  | 1.0000  0.0456 0.0000 | 0.4782  0.0218  0.0000
B  || 0.2   $3000  | 0.0000  1.0000 0.0026 | 0.0000  0.1995  0.0005
0  || 0.3   $0     | 0.0000  0.0000 1.0000 | 0.0000  0.0000  0.3000
---||--------------|-----------------------|------------------------
                                             0.4782  0.2213  0.3005

(As you can see, the 0.2 fraction from C devolved to 0, the row below it. Also, B managed to pick up more of the sales from C thanks to being cheaper than A.)

Naturally, this whole process repeats for each car that sells out its entire run.

In sum:

  • Players enter one or two cars.
  • Cars go into a table which converts stats into desirability scores in each demographic.
  • Cars go into tables for each demographic, sorting out sales by price bracket.
  • As cars sell out their entire production, customers shift attention to the remaining options on the market.

...and at the end, all the sales numbers can be posted with how much of their seed capital each car recouped in profits.

So, yeah. That's my plan. Thoughts, suggestions, criticisms?
Last edited by Packbat on Sun Dec 06, 2015 12:57 am, edited 1 time in total.
<<

T16

User avatar

8-Star Beta Tester
8-Star Beta Tester

Posts: 468

Joined: Tue Oct 19, 2010 1:49 pm

Location: Denmark

Cars: AW11, 405 T16

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 10:08 am

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

I moved the thread to Community Challenges & Competitions
<<

Killrob

User avatar

Developer - Lead Beta Tester/Producer/German Efficiency Expert
Developer - Lead Beta Tester/Producer/German Efficiency Expert

Posts: 3711

Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2011 1:00 am

Location: Lower Hutt, New Zealand

Cars: I owned a Twingo... totally bad-ass!

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 10:11 am

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

The only problem I see with this is that you will hate your life if "too many" people join in. :P
<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 11:09 am

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

@T16: Thanks! I didn't know if it was right to put something that's not a competition yet in the folder - I will try to file my threads correctly in the future. :)

@Killrob: Thanks for the vote of confidence! :D

In the worst case scenario (i.e. many cars selling most or all of their production runs in the first 50% of sales), I'll say "screw it", crack open Matlab, and do it right. :geek: Hopefully I'll be all right - Der Bayer's last CTC had 46 cars and only 3 sold out their entire production runs by my count. I might cap the number of entrants at 25.
<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 3:19 pm

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

Packbat wrote:
  • Players will choose factory size and % cost markup in-game for each trim. (Is factory size by trim or by model? I'll need to figure that out before I start the competition.)

Okay, in my test build, when I changed the factory size for one trim, it changed the factory size for the other. That makes sense.

In that case, my rule will be that the max production figures given are max production of that trim, and total production out of the factory is split between trims. So if you can build 600/mo of A or 500/mo of B, you can build 300/mo of A plus 250/mo of B, 240/mo of A plus 300/mo of B, 60/mo of A plus 450/mo of B, or whatever fractions of A and B so long as the fractions add up to 100%.

That will make my job a little harder (my spreadsheet will have to track models selling out, not trims), but I like it, so that's what I'll do.
<<

07CobaltGirl

User avatar

Queen of Track Building

Posts: 1613

Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2013 11:47 am

Location: Atlanta, GA, USA

Cars: Chevy Cobalt

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 4:02 pm

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

Daunting task for you, but sounds very intriguing.
<<

koolkei

User avatar

Posts: 947

Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2015 10:35 pm

Cars: a mini 2 wheeled single cyl car :D

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 4:48 pm

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

(The following is the really complicated part.)


i stopped reading for now. my head hurts. my english is failing me. i cant crunch all of that info at once.

okay i finished reading all of it (after reading twice or thrice). im gonna try to make it short

TL;DR
    - make a car like any other competition/ or 2
    - but have engineering time limit
    - if 1 car, then 100% of the engineering time. if 2 car then, 100% of the larger value+(50%*the smaller value)
    - bigger factory= more cars produced= possibility of more sales = more tooling cost penalty
    - make compromise between stats and costs because better stats =/= better car sales
    - if you choose factory too small and run out of car= more sales for the next best car
correct me on this?

also sorry for my english.

again. i miss having 'spoiler' feature on a forum
Last edited by koolkei on Thu Dec 03, 2015 12:29 am, edited 1 time in total.
<<

Zabhawkin

User avatar

Turbocharged
Turbocharged

Posts: 365

Joined: Mon Jun 25, 2012 5:26 pm

Cars: 13 Nissan Pathfinder
99 Nissan Frontier
84 Jeep CJ7 (rock crawler)

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 5:33 pm

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

I think DerBayer did something very similar quite a while back.
Desert Mountains Automotive Specializing in high reliability cars and trucks for more demanding needs.
<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Wed Dec 02, 2015 11:39 pm

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

@07CobaltGirl: Yeah, a little, but glad to hear it's intriguing!

@koolkei: Pretty much correct. The one point I see is: a bigger factory doesn't have a bigger engineering time penalty, though, just a bigger tooling-cost penalty. But it also has a reduction in manufacturing costs, which means a bigger margin on each car if you charge the same price. Other than that one thing, it's a good summary.

@Zabhawkin: Indeed - Der Bayer's Car Tycoon Challenges are the reason why I thought I could do one myself. The in-game calculations for engineering and manufacturing make things a lot easier for me, though.
<<

koolkei

User avatar

Posts: 947

Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2015 10:35 pm

Cars: a mini 2 wheeled single cyl car :D

Post Thu Dec 03, 2015 1:33 am

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

well then. what's the downside to having bigger factories?
edit: more question

you said up there you might allow team. what if a team/2 companies want to submit 3 cars?

1 for each of them for themselves, and the last one a reslut of the partnership.
how do you count the engineering time on that case? or is that even allowed?
<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Thu Dec 03, 2015 5:12 am

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

Another confusion I have managed to unearth in myself: I seem to have been reading the per-day production numbers as per-month production numbers. That explains why they were so low. :lol:

koolkei wrote:well then. what's the downside to having bigger factories?

Bigger factory = bigger tooling costs. The larger the factory, the more cars you need to sell to break even.

you said up there you might allow team. what if a team/2 companies want to submit 3 cars?

1 for each of them for themselves, and the last one a reslut of the partnership.
how do you count the engineering time on that case? or is that even allowed?

I'm still thinking about the engineering-time question, but at least for this contest, that kind of collaboration would not be allowed. Each player would only be allowed to enter once - either as a solo competitor or part of a team - and each entrant - solo or team - would only be allowed 2 cars.

In later competitions, I might let each person enter as a company but allow companies to collaborate - selling each other engines, for example - but that will have to wait for later.
<<

PMP1337

Naturally Aspirated

Posts: 250

Joined: Thu Aug 14, 2014 9:56 am

Location: Lisbon

Cars: Fiat Brava

Post Fri Dec 04, 2015 9:37 am

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

Zabhawkin wrote:I think DerBayer did something very similar quite a while back.

He did but back then the game didn't have market calculations, actually, his challenge helped the devds with the calculations. I helped with the testing.
Now that the game calculates everything it's a lot easier, you "only" have to look at the market group scores and compare.
Image
<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Fri Dec 04, 2015 9:48 am

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

Using the in-game market groups is an option, but at least for this competition I'm planning to generate my own. I'll probably base them on a sampling of the in-game market demos, but I like the theory behind my formula and want to run with it.
<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Sat Dec 05, 2015 12:18 pm

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

Okay, did more experimentation, learned more things.

  • Engine tooling costs are not included in the trim tooling costs, but do scale with factory size.
  • The game does not remember factory sizes at all. It's not stored in the trim or the model .lua files.
  • Tooling costs for both engines and trims increase faster than production numbers.

What that means for the competition is just two things:
  • Entrants must specify factory size with each model entered.
  • If the same engine is used in two different models, entrants must pay the full engine tooling costs for both models. If two variants of the engine are used on two trims of the same model, the greater-plus-half-the-lesser cost-sharing rule applies. If the same variant of the same family is used for both trims of a model, the tooling cost is only paid once, not 1.5x or 2x.

So that's significant progress. Next step: deciding on the market demographics.
<<

Packbat

User avatar

Posts: 953

Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2015 4:07 pm

Location: Eastern Time Zone, USA

Cars: I, being poor, have only my dreams

Post Sat Dec 05, 2015 1:31 pm

Re: Planning my first Car Tycoon Challenge

Given my experience with the Hoon Competition, I think I'll give entrants a template for their entries - something like:
Entry Format

Please copy+paste the following into your PM, fill in the blanks with your information, and attach all files.
  Code:
[b]Company Name[/b]:
[b]Nationality[/b]:

[b]Vehicle #1 Name[/b]:

[b]Factory #1 City[/b]:
[b]Factory #1 Size[/b]:

[b]Vehicle #2 Name[/b]:

[b]Factory #2 City[/b]: [i](if same factory, leave blank)[/i]
[b]Factory #2 Size[/b]: [i](if same factory, leave blank)[/i]

[b]Notes[/b]:


Example:
Company Name: Packbat Auto Works (PAW)
Nationality: US

Vehicle #1 Name: Pteropus C

Factory #1 City: Baltimore, MD
Factory #1 Size: Large 1

Vehicle #2 Name: Jubatus E

Factory #2 City: Baltimore, MD
Factory #2 Size: Medium 1

Notes: Fittingly, given that Baltimore is a port, both cars are great big rocking boats.
Next

Return to Community Challenges & Competitions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests